Railroad focuses on Chicago congestion to win merger support

January 21, 2016

Railroad focuses on Chicago congestion to win merger support

By Micah Maidenberg, Crain’s Chicago Business

Canadian Pacific Railway is emphasizing Chicago track congestion in a ramped-up effort to persuade Norfolk Southern shareholders and railroad regulators to approve a merger of the two companies.Website Insert Gathering of Professionals copy

In a report released today, the Alberta-based railroad says that if it completes its hostile bid to merge with Norfolk, it could shift at least some freight traffic to places such as Buffalo, N.Y.; Elkhart, Ind.; and Kansas City, Mo., avoiding the Chicago area.

Canadian Pacific spokesman Martin Cej declined to discuss how a merger would affect the number of local jobs, other than to say less congestion in the region for other carriers is a “net-net improvement” for the broader economy and job creation.

But some positions could be lost if the companies merge. Canadian Pacific has employees at its Bensenville intermodal yard, while Norfolk has intermodal facilities in Englewood, on 106th Street on the Southeast Side and elsewhere in the region.

Norfolk Southern, which is fighting the proposed merger, rejects Canadian’s assertion that a combination would ease traffic jams that form as several freight railroads, Amtrak and Metra try to move around and through the region.


James Clements, vice president of strategic planning and transportation services at Canadian Pacific, acknowledges that both sides “don’t even agree on the basic set of facts.” Canadian Pacific thinks at least four or five trains a day could be diverted from the area if the firms combine, he said.

That’s significantly more than Norfolk’s estimates. Last month, James Squires, CEO of the Norfolk, Va.-based railroad, said less than one train per day of current traffic from both firms would shift out of the area.

But Canadian Pacific says in the new report that the larger company could build “manifest trains,” or trains with cars heading in the same direction but to different destinations, in Norfolk’s yard in Elkhart rather than here.

Canadian Pacific also could skip Chicago by routing traffic from eastern Canada or the northeast U.S. through Detroit and down to Kansas City, according to its report. Buffalo would become a more important “gateway” for trains heading east, the report says, handling work now completed in Chicago.

The rail bottleneck in Chicago is a function of the region’s position in the center of the North American freight network. The area has nearly 3,900 miles of track and more than 50 freight yards, and it handles the movement of 1,300 freight and passenger trains each day, according to the Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning.

Click here to read the full story.


Previous post:

Next post: